欧洲长剑 VS 欧洲刺剑 Longsword VS Rapier【中国刀吧】_百度贴吧
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&签到排名：今日本吧第个签到，本吧因你更精彩，明天继续来努力！
本吧签到人数：0成为超级会员，使用一键签到本月漏签0次！成为超级会员，赠送8张补签卡连续签到：天&&累计签到：天超级会员单次开通12个月以上，赠送连续签到卡3张
关注：25,832贴子：
欧洲长剑 VS 欧洲刺剑 Longsword VS Rapier收藏
非常精彩 欧洲长剑 VS 欧洲刺剑 Longsword VS Rapier
Introduction of Nick
--- the user of rapier I specialise in Italian Rapier combat, primarily from Ridolfo Capo Ferro, of which I published a translation in 2007 and have run numerous classes around the world, but always researching and developing from other sources.Also study German longsword, grosse messer, Hutton Sabre and starting smallsword. Always happy to pick up and train or fight with anything, against anything. I won both HEMAC European Rapier Competitions in 2009.
Nick简介（持刺剑的一方）精通意大利Ridolfo Capo Ferro刺剑，2007年在欧洲公开发表意大利刺剑译文以及举办大量刺剑课程培训，并获得2009年欧洲刺剑竞赛冠军，同时研究德国双手剑术。
手机无力,建议转一份,顺便问问哪方占优?
Nick is the one of the finest player of rapier in European Rapier , but with the light and weakness in defense of the rapier to fight against the longsword ,obviously not on position of advantage , his rival Mike ,almostly level in longsword than Nick .so we think that the longsword take the position of advantage .
长剑点数上占优
掌主的眼光越来越专业了 。
我是根据文字看的,手机无力
原来你是看上面的英文，那个英文评论是我写的。
那到底占不占优呀,写英文不如打汉字,谁都以为你是转的
天津金世记科技提供优质推刀推刀,渐开线拉刀等,联系***拥有丰富设计经验 联系 /
所谓刺剑就是贵族玩具，没有硬格挡技法，是无法和战场上应用的手半剑 ，双手剑对抗的。大家可以看到即使是欧洲刺剑高手面对水平相仿的双手长剑对手也无法占优势 。
只要不被刺中要害，一剑换一剑，长剑就能直接解决战斗了
欧洲长剑一方两种有效应对战术：犁势起势的防守反击 对峙中突然抢攻
这种冷兵器跨越交流能充分展示各个冷兵器的攻防技法。这里欧洲长剑一方属于优势，能够得心应手的发挥，更全面更精彩地展示欧洲长剑犁势起势的防守进攻技法。随便提一下，欧洲长剑双手转换成单手突刺，是由于对手刺剑不能格挡防守有机会发挥 。
怎么感觉看过这个视频
欧洲长剑一方展示的中位起势攻防技法以及变化 ，堪称目前欧洲长剑最具代表性的，此外欧洲刺剑技法，对使用单手剑法也非常有提高价值。
任何武器能存在都是有道理的。其实这里面的Longsword比较接近于中世纪早期的品种，那时候盔甲还不是非常强，这种剑纯粹为格斗而设计。反观Rapier则是16世纪才出现的东西，要不是因为那时候火***出现使得钣金铠被淘汰，这种过渡性武器原本一无是处。Rapier其实就是冷兵器跟热兵器交替时代出现的过渡性产物，毕竟那时候的***发射很麻烦，Rapier作为轻便的冷兵器必然是很好的选择。所以Longsword比Rapier肯定更偏向实战，我觉得这两种对打本身就很不公平。其实我感觉视频里的防护服才是亮点，即使是没开锋的Longsword，用力一刺必然也要命，不知道他们的防护服得多少钱一件。。。
Rapier 重量长度和longsword差不多，主要是弹性突出 ，无法格挡防守依靠步法身法。
中世纪战场上强悍的双手大剑 Great Sword Claymore 苏格兰斩剑
这种双手大剑得多沉？
3-4磅 。Nick不久将发布德国双手大剑VS长剑 ，剑盾 ，刺剑实战视频 。
Nick论德国双手巨剑 ZweihanderWe have built zweihanders for sparring purposes . We used to own steel zweihanders, but they cannot be safely sparred with.We have used zweihanders against rapier, longsword, sword and buckler and shield. The zweihander has a tremendous advantage. We did many high contact sparring tests where one person used the zweihander against upto three opponents at once who used a mixture of sword types. The majority of the time the zweihander was able to win. This is why it was used against multple opponents in defence of towns and flags. Blade breaking is a risk against a zweihander, but your main worry are reach and leverage. A Zweihander can deal crippllng leg cuts and body thrusts out of the reach of almost any sword, but it can also batter or force through many guards and parries. For a start, most sword fighting systems are for civilian fighting, as the sword is typically a 2nd or even 3rd weapon in war. Clearly a civilian cannot carry a zweihander. They also can be problematic in any kind of confined spaces, not just maneouverng space but as with any long weapon, they suffer at close quarters with the grips. In a straight up comparison though, you wouldn't want to come up against one all things being equal.
德国双手大剑VS长剑 我实在无法想象何种防护服足以承受双手大剑的打击，估计戴了头盔都会被抡成脑震荡。不过用剑盾打双手大剑应该胜算很大，所谓尾大不掉，用盾把双手大剑卡死，再用腾出来的剑猛砍就行
这种问题和尝试上文提到 ，防护护具一直是不可忽视的重要问题 。
看来也不沉啊
跟唐刀都差不多
登录百度帐号