This service is more advanced with JavaScript available, learn more at http://activatejavascript.org
You're seeing our new article page and we'd like your opinion,&
Evaluating climate change vulnerability assessments: a case study of research focusing on the built environment in northern CanadaJames D. FordDepartment of GeographyMcGill UniversityClara ChampalleDepartment of GeographyMcGill UniversityPamela TudgeDepartment of GeographyMcGill UniversityRudy RiedlspergerDepartment of GeographyMemorial University of NewfoundlandTrevor BellDepartment of GeographyMemorial University of NewfoundlandErik SparlingRisk Sciences InternationalOriginal ArticleDOI:
10.-014-9543-xCite this article as: Ford, J.D., Champalle, C., Tudge, P. et al. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Change (67. doi:10.-014-9543-x
Vulnerability assessments (VAs) have been widely used to understand the risks posed by climate change and identify opportunities for adaptation. Few studies, however, have evaluated VAs from the perspective of intended knowledge users or with reference to established best practices. In this paper, we identify and evaluate VAs focusing on the built environment in northern Canada. We document 16 completed VAs, which range from engineering-based studies of the vulnerability of specific infrastructural assets (e.g. building foundations, roads) to community-based assessments characterizing the vulnerability of the built environment in general in specific communities. We then evaluate projects based on the extent to which they incorporate best practices for vulnerability assessment, informed by a review of the scholarship and interviews with practitioners and knowledge users in the north (n = 21). While completed VAs have increased our understanding of the risks posed by climate change, none perform well across all evaluation criteria, and interviewees identified the need for improvement to VAs to inform decision making. Specifically, there is a need for greater emphasis on stakeholder engagement and effective communication of research findings, and interdisciplinary collaboration to capture the multiple drivers of vulnerability, cost impacts, and examine the performance of infrastructural assets under different climate scenarios.VulnerabilityClimate changeBuilt environmentNorthern CanadaArcticLiterature reviewEvaluation frameworkAdger WN (2006) Vulnerability. Glob Environ Chang 16:268-281Adger WN, Agrawala S, Mirza MMQ, Conde C, O’Brien K, Pulhin J, Pulwarty R, Smit B, Takahashi K (2007) Assessment of adaptation practices, options, constraints and capacity. In: Parry ML, Canziani OF, Palutikof JP, van der Linden PJ, Hanson CE (eds) Climate change 2007: impacts, adaptation and vulnerability contribution of working group II to the fourth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeAdger WN, Eakin H, Winkels A (2009) Nested and teleconnected vulnerabilities to environmental change. Front Ecol Environ 7:150-157Andrachuk M (2008) An assessment of the vulnerability of Tuktoyaktuk to environmental and socio-economic changes. Master of Arts, University of Guelph, GuelphAndrachuk A, Pearce T (2010a) Vulnerability and adaptation to climate change in two communities in the Inuvialuit Settlement Region. In: Hovelsrud G, Smit B (eds) C***IAR: Community Adaptation and Vulnerability in Arctic Regions. Springer, DordrechtAndrachuk M, Pearce T (2010b) Vulnerability and adaptation in Two communities in the Inuvialuit settlement region. In: Hovelsrud GK, Smit B (eds) Community adaptation and vulnerability in arctic regions. Springer, NetherlandsAndrachuk M, Smit B (2012) Community-based vulnerability assessment of Tuktoyaktuk, NWT, Canada to environmental and socio-economic changes. Reg Environ Chang 12:867-885Arctic Council A (2013) Arctic Resilience Interim Report. In: Centre SEIaSR (ed), StockholmBauer A, Feichtinger J, Steurer R (2012) The governance of climate change adaptation in 10 OECD countries: challenges and approaches. J Environ Policy Plan 14:279-304Berrang-Ford L, Ford JD, Patterson J (2011) Are we adapting to climate change? Glob Environ Chang 21:25-33BGC Engineering (2011) Climate change vulnerability assessment for NWT highway 3: Government of Northwest Territories, Department of Transportation. p 212Boucher M, Guimond A Assessing the vulnerability of Ministère des Transports du Québec infrastructures in Nunavik in a context of thawing permafrost and development of an adaptation strategy. In. Proc 15th International Conference on Cold Regions Engineering, Quebec, Canada, August 19-22, 2012Boyle M, Dowlatabadi H (2011) Anticipatory adaptation in marginalised communities within developed countries. In: Ford JD, Berrang-Ford L (eds) Climate change adaptation in developed nations: from theory to practice. Springer, DordrechtBrunner R, Steelman TA, Coe-Juell L, Cromley CM, Edwards CM, Tucker DW (eds) (2005) Adaptive governance: integrating science, policy, and decision-making, Vol. Columbia University Press, New YorkBudreau D, McBean G (2007) Climate change, adaptive capacity and policy direction in the Canadian North: can we learn anything from the collapse of the east coast cod fishery? Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Chang 12:Burton I, Lim B (2005) Adaptation policy framework for climate change. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeBurton I, Huq S, Lim B, Pilifosova O, Schipper EL (2002) From impacts assessment to adaptation priorities: the shaping of adaptation policy. Clim Pol 2:145-159Calihoo C (2008) Hall Beach Nunavut: Climate Change Adaptation Action Plan. Hall Beach, Nunavut (ATULIQTUQ: Action and Adaptation in Nunavut). In: Government of Nunavut, Canadian Institute of Planners, Natural Resources Canada, Indian and Northern Affairs Canada (eds)Calihoo C, Romaine T (2010) Cambridge Bay Climate Change Adaptation Action Plan (ATULIQTUQ: Action and Adaptation in Nunavut). In: Government of Nunavut, Canadian Institute of Planners, Natural Resources Canada, Indian and Northern Affairs Canada (eds)Cameron ES (2012) Securing Indigenous politics: a critique of the vulnerability and adaptation approach to the human dimensions of climate change in the Canadian Arctic. Glob Environ Chang 22(1):103-114Cutter SL (2003) The vulnerability of science and the science of vulnerability. Ann Assoc Am Geogr 93:1-12de Bruin K, Dellink RB, Ruijs A, Bolwidt L, van Buuren A, Graveland J, de Groot RS, Kuikman PJ, Reinhard S, Roetter RP, Tassone VC, Verhagen A, van Ierland EC (2009) Adapting to climate change in The Netherlands: an inventory of climate adaptation options and ranking of alternatives. Clim Chang 95:23-45de Wilde P, Coley D (2012) The implications of a changing climate for buildings. Build Environ 55:1-7Dovers S (2009) Normalizing adaptation. Glob Environ Chang 19:4-6Eakin H, Winkels A, Sendzimir J (2009) Nested vulnerability: exploring cross-scale linkages and vulnerability teleconnections in Mexican and Vietnamese coffee systems. Environ Sci Pol 12:398-412Ebi KL, Burton I (2008) Identifying practical adaptation options: an approach to address climate change-related health risks. Environ Sci Pol 11:359-369Engle NL (2011) Adaptive capacity and its assessment. Glob Environ Change-Hum Policy Dimens 21:647-656Ford JD, Pearce T (2010) What we know, do not know, and need to know about climate change vulnerability in the western Canadian Arctic: a systematic literature review. Environ Res Lett 5:14008Ford JD, Pearce T (2012) Climate change vulnerability and adaptation research focusing on the Inuit subsistence sector in Canada: directions for future research. Can Geogr-Geogr Can 56:275-287Ford JD, Smit B (2004) A framework for assessing the vulnerability of communities in the Canadian arctic to risks associated with climate change. Arctic 57:389-400Ford J, Smit B, Wandel J (2006) Vulnerability to climate change in the arctic: a case study from Arctic Bay, Canada. Glob Environ Change-Hum Policy Dimens 16:145-160Ford J, Pearce T, Smit B, Wandel J, Allurut M, Shappa K, Ittusujurat H, Qrunnut K (2007) Reducing vulnerability to climate change in the Arctic: the case of Nunavut, Canada. Arctic 60:150-166Ford JD, Smit B, Wandel J, Allurut M, Shappa K, Ittusarjuat H, Qrunnut K (2008) Climate change in the Arctic: current and future vulnerability in two Inuit communities in Canada. Geogr J 174:45-62Ford JD, Bell T, St-Hilaire-Gravel D (2010a) Vulnerability of community infrastructure to climate change in Nunavut: a case study from Arctic Bay. In: Hovelsrud GK, Smit B (eds) Community adaptation and vulnerability in arctic regions. Springer, Springer NetherlandsFord JD, Berrang Ford L, King M, Furgal C (2010b) Climate change policy responses for Canada’s Inuit population: the importance of and opportunities for adaptation. Glob Environ Chang 20:177-191Ford JD, Keskitalo ECH, Smith T, Pearce T, Berrang-Ford L, Duerden F, Smit B (2010c) Case study and analogue methodologies in climate change vulnerability research. Wiley Interdiscip Rev-Clim Chang 1:374-392Ford JD, Pearce T, Duerden F, Furgal C, Smit B (2010d) Climate change policy responses for Canada’s Inuit population: the importance of and opportunities for adaptation. Glob Environ Change-Hum Policy Dimens 20:177-191Ford JD, Smith TR, Berrang-Ford L (2011) Canadian federal support for climate change and health research compared with the risks posed. Am J Public Health 101:814-821Ford JD, Bolton K, Shirley J, Pearce T, Tremblay M, Westlake M (2012a) Mapping human dimensions of climate change research in the canadian arctic. Ambio 41:808-822Ford JD, Bolton KC, Shirley J, Pearce T, Tremblay M, Westlake M (2012b) Research on the human dimensions of climate change in Nunavut, Nunavik, and Nunatsiavut: a literature review and gap analysis. Arctic 65:289-304Ford J, Knight M, Pearce T (2013a) Assessing the ‘usability’ of climate change research for decision-making: a case study of the Canadian International Polar Year. Glob Environ Chang 23(5):Ford J, McDowell G, Shirley J, Gough W, Siewierski R, Pitre M, Duerden F, Pearce T, Adams P, Statham S (2013b) The dynamic multiscale nature of climate change vulnerability: An Inuit harvesting example. Ann Assoc Am Geogr 103(5):Fuchs S, Birkmann J, Glade T (2012) Vulnerability assessment in natural hazard and risk analysis: current approaches and future challenges. Nat Hazards 64:Fussel HM (2007) Adaptation planning for climate change: concepts, assessment approaches, and key lessons. Sustain Sci 2:265-275Gearheard S, Shirley J (2007) Challenges in community-research relationships: learning from natural science in Nunavut. Arctic 60:62-74Gearheard S, Pocernich M, Stewart R, Sanguya J, Huntington HP (2010) Linking Inuit knowledge and meteorological station observations to understand changing wind patterns at Clyde River, Nunavut. Clim Chang 100:267-294Glantz M (1991) The use of analogies in forecasting ecological and societal responses to global warming. Environment 33:27-33IMG Golder Corporation (2012a) Good Environmental Practices for Northern Mining and Necessary Infrastructure Task 2 Report. Nunavut Regional Adaptation Collaborative (RAC) In: Government of Nunavut: Department of Economic Development and Transportation (ed), Cambridge BayIMG Golder Corporation (2012b) Vulnerability Assessment of the Mining Sector to Climate Change Task 1 Report. Nunavut Regional Adaptation Collaborative (RAC) In: Government of Nunavut: Department of Economic Development and Transportation (ed), Cambridge BayGoulding H (2011) Yukon water: An assessment of climate change vulnerabilities. In: Yukon EY (ed)Hallegatte S (2009) Strategies to adapt to an uncertain climate change. Glob Environ Chang 19(2):240-247. doi:
Hallegatte S, Hourcade J-C, Ambrosi P (2007) Using climate analogues for assessing climate change economic impacts in urban areas. Clim Chang 82:47-60Hallegatte S, Przyluski V, Vogt-Schilb A (2011) Building world narratives for climate change impact, adaptation and vulnerability analyses. Nat Clim Chang 1:151-155Hayhurst T, Zeeg T (2010) Whale Cove (TIKIRARJUAQ) Climate Change Plan. In: ATULIQTUQ: Action and Adaptation in Nunavut. Whale Cover N, Government of Nunavut, the Canadian Institute of Planners, Natural Resources Canada and Indian and Northern Affairs Canada (ed)Hennessey R, Jones S, Swales S, Duerden F (2011) Dawson climate change adaptation plan, Revised Edition. In. Northern Climate ExChange, Yukon Research Centre, Yukon College, WhitehorseHennessey R, Stuart S, Duerden F (2012) Mayo region climate change adaptation plan. In, WhitehorseTHinkel J (2011) “Indicators of vulnerability and adaptive capacity”: towards a clarification of the science-policy interface. Glob Environ Change-Hum Policy Dimens 21:198-208Holsten A, Kropp JP (2012) An integrated and transferable climate change vulnerability assessment for regional application. Nat Hazards 64:Holubec Consulting Inc. (2008) Flat loop thermosyphon foundations in warm permafrost government of Northwest Territories. p 121Hovelsrud G, Smit B (eds) (2010) Community adaptation and vulnerability in arctic regions, Vol. Springer, DordrechtINAC (2010) Sharing knowledge for a better future: adaptation and clean energy experiences in a changing climate. Indian and Northern Affairs, CanadaIPCC (2007a) Climate Change 2007: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. Working Group II Contribution to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Fourth Assessment Report. In, GenevaIPCC (2007b) Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. In, GenevaIPCC (2012) Managing the Risks of Extreme Events and Disasters to Advance Climate Change Adaptation. In: Field CB, Barros V, Stocker TF, Qin D, Dokken DJ, Ebi KL, Mastrandrea MD, Mach KJ, Plattner G-K, Allen SK, Tignor M, Midgley PM (eds) A Special Report of Working Groups I and II of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, and New York, NY, USA, p 582Johnson K, Arnold E (2010) Kugluktuk Climate Change Adaptation Plan. In: ATULIQTUQ: Action and Adaptation in Nunavut. Whale Cover N, Government of Nunavut, the Canadian Institute of Planners, Natural Resources Canada and Indian and Northern Affairs Canada (ed)Kazmierczak A, Carter J (2010) Adaptation to Climate Change using Green and blue Infrastructure: a database of case studies. Interreg IVC Green and blue space adaptation for urban areas and eco towns (GRaBS) project University of Manchester, ManchesterKeskitalo ECH (2009) Governance in vulnerability assessment: the role of decision-making networks in determining local vulnerability and adaptive capacity. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Chang 14:185-201Keskitalo ECH, Kulyasova AA (2009) The role of governance in community adaptation to climate change. Polar Res 28:60-70Keskitalo ECH, Dannevig H, Hovelsrud GK, West JJ, Swartling AG (2011) Adaptive capacity determinants in developed states: examples from the Nordic countries and Russia. Reg Environ Chang 11:579-592Laidler GJ, Ford JD, Gough WA, Ikummaq T, Gagnon AS, Kowal S, Qrunnut K, Irngaut C (2009) Travelling and hunting in a changing Arctic: assessing Inuit vulnerability to sea ice change in Igloolik, Nunavut. Clim Chang 94:363-397Lemos MC, Morehouse BJ (2005) The co-production of science and policy in integrated climate assessments. Glob Environ Change-Hum Policy Dimens 15:57-68Lemos MC, Kirchhoff CJ, Ramprasad V (2012) Narrowing the climate information usability gap. Nat Clim Chang 2:789-794Li G, Dovers S (2011) Integrated assessment of climate change impacts on urban settlements: lessons from five Australian cases. In: Ford JD, Berrang-Ford L (eds) Climate change adaptation in developed nations: from theory to practice. Springer, DordrechtLiu J, Dietz T, Carpenter SR, Alberti M, Folke C, Moran E, Pell AN, Deadman P, Kratz T, Lubchenco J, Ostrom E, Ouyang Z, Provencher W, Redman CL, Schneider SH, Taylor WW (2007) Complexity of Coupled Human and Natural Systems. In, Book 317Lorch R (2005) What lessons must be learned from the tsunami? Build Res Inf 33:209-211Lynch AH, Brunner RD (2007) Context and climate change: an integrated assessment for Barrow, Alaska. Clim Chang 82:93-111Malone EL, Engle NL (2011) Evaluating regional vulnerability to climate change: purposes and methods. Wiley Interdiscip Rev-Clim Chang 2:462-474Matthews R, Sydneysmith R (2010) Climate change and institutional capacity in an ‘Arctic Gateway’ City: a C***IAR Case Study of Whitehorse. In: Hovelsrud GK, Smit B (eds) C***IAR: Community Adaptation and Vulnerability in Arctic Regions. Springer, NetherlandsMcClymont Peace D, Myers E (2012) Community-based participatory process-climate change and health adaptation program for Northern First Nations and Inuit in Canada. Int J Circumpolar Health 71:18412. doi:
Nelson FE, Anisimov AO, Shiklomanov NI (2002) Climate change and hazard zonation in the circum-arctic permafrost regions. Nat Hazards 26:203-225O’Brien KL, Leichenko RM (2000) Double exposure: assessing the impacts of climate change within the context of economic globalization. Glob Environ Chang 10:221-232O’Brien K, Eriksen S, Nygaard LP, Schjolden A (2007) Why different interpretations of vulnerability matter in climate change discourses. Clim Pol 7:73-88Pearce TD, Ford JD, Laidler GJ, Smit B, Duerden F, Allarut M, Andrachuk M, Baryluk S, Dialla A, Elee P, Goose A, Ikummaq T, Joamie E, Kataoyak F, Loring E, Meakin S, Nickels S, Shappa K, Shirley J, Wandel J (2009) Community collaboration and climate change research in the Canadian Arctic. Polar Res 28:10-27Pearce T, Ford J, Prno J, Duerden F, Pittman J, Beaumier M, Berrang-Ford L, Smit B (2010) Climate change and mining in Canada. Mittig Adapt Strat Glob Chang. doi:
Pearce T, Ford J, Prno J, Duerden F, Pittman J, Beaumier M, Berrang-Ford L, Smit B (2011a) Climate change and mining in Canada. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Chang 16:347-368Pearce T, Ford JD, Duerden F, Smit B, Andrachuk M, Berrang-Ford L, Smith T (2011b) Advancing adaptation planning for climate change in the Inuvialuit Settlement Region (ISR): a review and critique. Reg Environ Chang 11:1-17Pearce T, Ford JD, Caron A, Kudlak BP (2012) Climate change adaptation planning in remote, resource-dependent communities: an Arctic example. Reg Environ Chang 12:825-837Pennesi K, Arokium J, McBean G (2012) Integrating local and scientific weather knowledge as a strategy for adaptation to climate change in the Arctic. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Chang 17:897-922Petheram L, Zander KK, Campbell BM, High C, Stacey N (2010) ‘Strange changes’: Indigenous perspectives of climate change and adaptation in NE Arnhem Land (Australia). Glob Environ Change-Hum Policy Dimens 20:681-692PIEVC (2008) Adapting to Climate Change: Canada’s first engineering vulnerability assessment of public infractructure. In: Engineers Canada (ed)Polsky C, Neff R, Yarnal B (2007) Building comparable global change vulnerability assessments: the vulnerability scoping diagram. Glob Environ Chang 17:472-485Preston BL, Westaway RM, Yuen EJ (2011a) Climate adaptation planning in practice: an evaluation of adaptation plans from three developed nations. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Chang 16:407-438Preston BL, Yuen EJ, Westaway RM (2011b) Putting vulnerability to climate change on the map: a review of approaches, benefits, and risks. Sustain Sci 6:177-202Prowse TD, Furgal C (2009) Northern Canada in a changing climate: major findings and conclusions. Ambio 38:290-292Prowse TD, Furgal C, Bonsai BR, Edwards TWD (2009a) Climatic conditions in northern Canada: past and future. Ambio 38:257-265Prowse TD, Furgal C, Bonsal BR, Peters DL (2009b) Climate impacts on Northern Canada: regional background. Ambio 38:248-256Prowse TD, Furgal C, Kessler E (2009c) Special issue: climate impacts on Northern Canada. Ambio 38:245Riedlinger D, Berkes F (2001) Contributions of traditional knowledge to understanding climate change in the Canadian Arctic. Polar Rec 37:315-328Sarewitz D, Pielke RA (2007) The neglected heart of science policy: reconciling supply of and demand for science. Environ Sci Pol 10:5-16Schilderman T (2004) Adapting traditional shelter for disaster mitigation and reconstruction: experiences with community-based approaches. Build Res Inf 32:414-426Schr?ter D, Polsky C, Patt AG (2005) Assessing vulnerabilities to the effects of global change: an eight step approach. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Chang 10:573-595Sherman MH, Ford J (2013) Stakeholder engagement in adaptation interventions: an evaluation of projects in developing nations. Climate Policy. doi:
Smit B, Pilifosova O (2001) Adaptation to climate change in the context of sustainable development and equity. In: McCarthy J, Canziani OF, Leary NA, Dokken DJ, White KS (eds) Climate change 2001: impacts, adaptation, vulnerability contribution of working group II to the third assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeSmit B, Pilifosova O (2003) From adaptation to adaptive capacity and vulnerability reduction. In: Smith J, Klein RTJ, Huq S (eds) Climate change, adaptive capacity, and development. Imperial College Press, LondonSmit B, Wandel J (2006) Adaptation, adaptive capacity, and vulnerability. Glob Environ Chang 16:282-292Soares MB, Gagnon AS, Doherty RM (2012) Conceptual elements of climate change vulnerability assessments: a review. Int J Clim Chang Strateg Manag 4:6-35Spinney JA, Pennesi KE (2013) When the river started underneath the land: social constructions of a ‘severe’ weather event in Pangnirtung, Nunavut, Canada. Polar Rec 49:362-372Stephenson SR, Smith LC, Agnew JA (2011) Divergent long-term trajectories of human access to the Arctic. Nat Clim Chang 1:156-160Turner B, Kasperson RE, Matson PA, McCarthy J, Corell R, Christensen L, Eckley N, Kasperson JX, Luers A, Martello ML, Polsky C, Pulsipher A, Schiller A (2003a) A framework for vulnerability analysis in sustainability science. Proc Natl Acad Sci 100(14):Turner BL, Matson PM, McCarthy JJ, Corell RW, Christensen L, Eckley N, Hovelsrud-Broda G, Kasperson JX, Kasperson RE, Luers A, Lavender B, Martello ML, Mathiesen S, Naylor R, Polsky C, Pulsipher A, Schiller A, Selin, Tyler N (2003b) Illustrating the coupled human-environment system for vulnerability analysis: three case studies. Proc Natl Acad Sci 100(14):Weatherhead E, Gearheard S, Barry RG (2010) Changes in weather persistence: insight from Inuit knowledge. Glob Environ Change-Hum Policy Dimens 20:523-528Wesche SD, Armitage DR (2013) Using qualitative scenarios to understand regional environmental change in the Canadian North. Reg Environ Chang 1-14. doi:
Wolf J, Allice I, Bell T (2013) Values, climate change, and implications for adaptation: evidence from two communities in Labrador, Canada. Glob Environ Change-Hum Policy Dimens 23:548-562Zhou F, Zhang A, Li R, Hoeve E, Majid A (2007) Potential climate change-induced permafrost degradation and building foundations: an assessment of impacts and costs for five case communities in the Northwest Territories. Potential cost impacts for adaptation of building foundations in the Northwest Territories. Ottawa, Natural Resources Canada
Buy (PDF)EUR&34,95
Unlimited access to full article
Instant download (PDF)
Price includes local sales tax if applicable
Export citation
Share article